Paul McCartney created an avant-garde piece, “Carnival of Light,” in 1967, showcasing The Beatles’ experimental side. Recorded for an art exhibition, this nearly 14-minute track featured chaotic sounds and phrases. Despite its brief public debut, it was never officially released. McCartney sought to include it in Beatles’ compilations, but it was vetoed and remains largely unheard today.
In the late 1960s, Paul McCartney became deeply involved in London’s underground art movement, influenced by pop art and innovative collectives like the Drury Lane Arts Lab. He had the chance to explore the avant-garde side of The Beatles by creating a piece for the 1967 exhibition
The Million Volt Light and Sound Rave. McCartney directed the band to record an experimental track, “Carnival of Light”, which lasted nearly 14 minutes and featured a free-form blend of sounds and phrases, reflecting a break from conventional music structures.
The recording took place on January 5, 1967, and was a chaotic production of guitars and echoes. Despite its creative intent, producer George Martin deemed the session unproductive. “This is ridiculous,” he remarked, prompting the band to return to more mainstream compositions like “Penny Lane.” Subsequently, “Carnival of Light” debuted at the Roundhouse Theatre’s light show on January 28, 1967, yet few listeners realised it was a Beatles creation.
McCartney later suggested including “Carnival of Light” in the Beatles’ Anthology 2 in 1996, but this was declined by fellow members, who viewed it unfavourably. Even with renewed interest in the piece over the years, including a mention for the 30th-anniversary remaster of
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, the track remains largely unreleased and hidden away, with McCartney stating, “The time has come for it to get its moment.” However, the avant-garde piece continues to elude public access.
In the 1960s, the British underground scene was flourishing, significantly impacting the arts, music, and culture. The Beatles were not only a musical phenomenon but also sought to experiment with new artistic expressions. McCartney’s involvement in the underground art movements of the time led to the creation of “Carnival of Light”, a lesser-known yet significant piece that demonstrated the band’s avant-garde aspirations. Despite its recording and brief public airing, it never received an official release or recognition within their discography, illustrating the tension between commercial success and artistic experimentation.
“Carnival of Light” exemplifies The Beatles’ exploration of avant-garde music during a period of cultural experimentation. Although they recorded the piece with great enthusiasm, its experimental nature led to its dismissal by the band members, reflecting a complexity in balancing artistic innovation with mainstream appeal. Despite McCartney’s desire to resurrect it in various compilations, the track remains largely overlooked, a hidden gem that highlights a different facet of The Beatles’ creative journey.
Original Source: americansongwriter.com