Why Merlot Deserves a Second Chance

Merlot has faced significant challenges since the impactful line in the film “Sideways,” however, it is crucial to reevaluate this grape. Despite prevailing misconceptions, Merlot stands as the world’s second-most widely cultivated red grape, originating from Bordeaux, where it enjoys widespread acclaim. This wine is not exclusively revered by the characters Miles and Jack – numerous esteemed winemakers are crafting exceptional Merlot that demands reconsideration.

Diverging from Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot offers a distinct taste profile, featuring softer tannins and immediate drinkability post-release. Prime examples of Merlot hail from Bordeaux, Bolgheri, Napa, Sonoma, and Washington State. Anticipate encountering notes of blueberry, black cherry, blackcurrant, and vanilla, alongside lush tannins and hints of soft leather or earthy undertones.

According to the insights of Mt. Brave winemaker Chris Carpenter, Merlot showcases depth, complexity, minerality, and a capacity for aging akin to Cabernet, but with its own unique characteristics. His 2019 Merlot from Napa Valley’s Mount Veeder, priced at $95, undergoes 21 months of aging in French oak, resulting in a splendid bouquet of blackberry and violet, complemented by nuances of spice and cocoa. Alternatively, Le Macchiole Messorio 2019, priced at $344, takes a different approach, crafted purely from Merlot and aged for 18 months in new oak. This offering exudes aromas of red berries and juniper, leading to flavors of blackberry, red cherry, aniseed, and butterscotch. While Bolgheri Merlot has the potential for extended cellaring, Le Macchiole owner Cinzia Merli attests to the immediate enjoyability of the 2019 vintage.

Another noteworthy contender is the Château Bélair-Monange 2018, priced at $275, a Saint-Émilion Grand Cru characterized by a nose of cassis, olive tapenade, and lavender, with refined tannins and flavors of blackberry preserve, violet, flint, and dried Mediterranean herbs. Owner Christian Moueix asserts that the wine’s vivid character matures and gains complexity over time, shedding any oak influence and developing a subtle minerality that endures for decades.

Therefore, if the renowned line from “Sideways” has dissuaded you from embracing Merlot, it is time to reassess and reacquaint yourself with this intricate and gratifying wine. Whether opting for a Napa Merlot such as Chris Carpenter’s or a Bordeaux offering like Château Bélair-Monange, the time has come to bestow this grape with the admiration it rightfully deserves. Here’s to Merlot!